
(16.08.2008)
- “You saw nothing in Hiroshima. Nothing.”
- “I saw everything.”
(Hiroshima, Mon Amour)
A hand, Mr. Masataka Segi says, a hand is the reason why I talk today. That thin hand, as it grabbed and grabbed and grabbed into nothing but air, desperately trying to find something to hold on to, that hand of the supposedly dead man amongst the endless pile of corpses. He had walked for hours through flat emptiness, a boy of 10 years, had treated on that blackened land that used to be his home town; he had walked over corpses and stepped on the dying to get to the hospital, to search for his father. He wolfed down the rice that kind women handed him on the way, he ate it all to the very last rice corn; that’s when I started to understand that my soul had died that day, Mr. Masataka Segi says, “how could I have eaten after everything I had seen?” He adds softly, but with determination: “I think the war destroyed my heart and spirit entirely”. Then he continues to talk about how he came to the hospital, how he stared into the endless row of faces of the injured, dying or dead, in hope of recognizing the features of his father. In the hospital, that’s where he saw it, while searching for the body of his father which would remain forever lost, he saw the hand and then he ran away without telling, ran away and cried and cried, leaving the man to his death amongst the already deceased. He would be the only witness to know that the man was still alive that day, he would be the only one, yet he didn’t, couldn’t speak. He had seen too much that day, too much for such a small boy to take in, so he silently ran. But the hand, it kept haunting him in his dreams for many, many years – and only on that one day in 1988 when he finally told his story in front of an audience of strangers those nightmares would stop. “I survived, so I believe it’s my responsibility to tell the story of the hand. To fulfill my duty towards that arm.” I have to talk about the hand, Mr. Matsataka Segi says, it’s what I’ve come here for today.

At six in the morning, the sun is not painful just yet, as it rises above the city of Hiroshima. It is the 6th of August 2008. We had arrived at Hiroshima two days earlier, had listened to lectures and testimonies, had wandered around aimlessly in the peace park, gazed at the A-bomb dome, had looked at memorials and talked and talked, but the one Hiroshima of the 6th of August 1945 had somehow remained out of reach. Perhaps because history is everywhere in Hiroshima, because they rebuilt the place for the sole reason to make it a landmark for the cruelties of war, perhaps because it is all over the place – the bomb and how it destroyed hundreds of thousands of lives – perhaps that’s why it can never fully be grasped. The A-bomb is still in the very air that one breathes in Hiroshima, in that same air that 63 years earlier a dying man’s hand would try to find something to hold on to, longing for a moment of stability amidst chaos and death and destruction. But how, how, how does one hold on to thin air, after all?
The sky was clear on August 6th back then, the sky is without a cloud on this day, too. By 8 o clock the heat stings, all the fans and cold cloths and water and parasols fail to protect people from rising temperatures. The crowd grows and grows, over 40,000 people it will finally be, gathered around the shrine in the very center of the peace park in Hiroshima. At 8.15 every sound stops in the vicinity, as 40,000 bow their heads in silence to mark the moment the bomb fell. In the distance, though, I can hear something that sounds like wailing, a gruesome noise that becomes ever more clear in the silence that has set upon the crowd. It is only half an hour later that I understand that what I took for weeping sounds was nothing but the battle cry of counter protesters trying to express their discontent with the government-led commemoration ceremonies.
We leave the ceremony behind once the speeches start – the prime minister of Japan is to speak amongst many other visitors, Hiroshima’s status as a victim is fully embraced this morning by the most prominent officials of the country; but Cheong-hee and I are too far away from the main stage anyways, and our Japanese is inexistent, so we prefer to wander around for a while instead. It does not take long and we run into a group of aging anarchists, one of a handful of leftist groups that are holding protests that morning; we start to talk with them about their reasons for coming here today. “Don’t get us wrong,” a man explains to us, “we are against the war just as well. But we are also against what this government has turned this ceremony into. We are against their continuous support and tolerance of the U.S. military in our country. We are against their most recent attempts at reinstating their own military in our country, against their attempts to buy new weapons to take part in all this militarization nonsense that happens in East Asia. We are against their primary focus on victimhood – so many suffered through the hands of Japan. We should look at all kinds of sufferings – we have been perpetrators as much as we have been victims. That’s why we have come here today.”
An hour later, I listen to the lecture of an important academic from the local university who also leads a high-profile NGO that is sponsored by a lot of government money. Hiroshima, he says, is a red flag for the left of Japan, but we here are all working at turning Hiroshima into something that the world can look out for, a model for peace building all over the world. There have been two processes of peace in Japan, he says – one that started in the late 19th century with the inner consolidation of Japan, which was then interrupted by World War II, after which the second peace process started. The longer the professor speaks, the more my agitation grows over his use of the word peace – yes, he admits, this first era of peace sadly coincided with Japan, too, having to take part in the big game for acquiring colonies and new territory. But that’s the road modernity took back then – and in the end, partial peace was reached after all on the islands of Japan. Hiroshima, he says, can stand as a grand example for rebuilding war-torn regions all over the world – this, in fact, is what their NGO is trying to achieve. Whenever he goes to one of those regions, the Sudans and Sierra Leones of this world, he says, one question that ordinary people always seem to have is how they themselves can benefit from peace building. They believe, he says, that in the end it is usually just about a bunch of NGO workers making big salaries, about local politicians learning a new more beneficial kind of peace lingo, and PhD students being able to gather some more material to build their careers on… It is hard to convince them, he acknowledges, hard to make people believe in peace. I look over to Cheong-hee, she listens silently, her face stone-cold; for 40 years, Korea was a colony of Japan, and up to this day, thousands of forced laborers, amongst them hundreds of former forced sex laborers commonly known as the Comfort Women – the few that are still alive of the hundreds of thousands that suffered and perished – have waited in vain for an apology from official Japan for what has been done to them so many years ago. Thousands of Korean forced laborers were in the city of Hiroshima when the bomb fell, too, we learn later on a guided tour through the peace park – the Japanese lady leading us through the park makes sure to add that the number that the Korean side gives – over 20,000 Korean deaths on that day – is probably much too high and cannot be trusted. “Why would she say that?” Cheong-hee says to me, as we stand in front of the Korean memorial for the dead – a memorial that has only been included in the peace park a few years ago after much pressure from the Korean side – “why on earth would she say that?”
Setsuko Marita speaks very softly, her eyes filled with tears for most of the time that she takes to speak in front of us, but despite that her voice never breaks, the flow of words never stops. She had been 1,4 kms away from the epicentre, she tells us, she was a school girl back then, they had been mobilized to work in a field nearby that morning, that’s why she wasn’t at the very city center on August 6th, a small coincidence, she says, that’s why she’s still alive. Some girls working in the field that morning had been more unfortunate, they had heard the airplane that would drop the bomb and looked up from their work to gaze at the sky. She herself, she heard nothing, she said, which probably saved her live – those that looked would have their faces burnt beyond recognition, but she was crouching, bent over her work, when the bomb fell that morning. That way my face stayed intact, she said, just the skin coming off my arms – she touches the old scars now while she speaks. 6,000 students were mobilized for work this morning, she says, only 1,000 of us survived that very day. “Many of my friends died that morning and were cremated at our school just as well.” What I saw, what I did, how can I speak about it, she says; we kicked the dying students to prevent them from clinging to us, she says; we dragged ourselves for hours through the destroyed city to get back to our school so that we could tell our teachers of what had happened, they surely would know what to do…
A few months later she was back at school, but her world had changed entirely. She and the other survivors were ridiculed for their looks by the healthy students; the teachers stumbled around the building all confused, not knowing what to teach now that their great Japan had been defeated. 2/3rd of the curriculum was no longer to be used then, what was there to teach really now that they had lost the war? Every once in a while a jeep by the American soldiers would stop in front of the school and come to pick young Setsuko Marita up – she was taken up the hill to the ABCC, the research center that the U.S. military had established soon afterwards where data of the aftermath was meticulously collected. Ms. Setsuko Marita now passes a copy of her own file around – look carefully at how much information they put together about me back then, she says, and no treatment was ever given up there, she adds bitterly. “They took pictures of me, too,” she says, “I wanted to get a hold of those as well, but they are in the U.S. now in some military archive, and the military informed me that I have no right to see them.” It was only in her early 20s that she learned what she suspects that the American officials had figured out rather early – that the A-bomb had left her barren. I lost every hope that I would ever get married, she says, and so did many of my friends who had gone through this just as well. What was there to do for us, she said, many of my friends joined Buddhist or Christian monasteries now, as marriage had become an impossibility for many of them – others, she adds now, they had to go another path. I wouldn’t want to talk about it, she says, but the truth is that many started to prostitute themselves, selling themselves to the U.S. soldiers stationed nearby. Even those who managed to get themselves married, she says, would suffer from mental problems for much of their lives, or would die from leukaemia years after the bomb. There was no counseling, there was no treatment – we were tired and listless all the time and just didn’t really understand why; the A-bomb, she says, it divided us and left a huge gap between people; the survivors just couldn’t compete with those who had not been near the bomb, their health was too poor, their mental state too fragile.
She met a survivor eventually and fell in love with him – everyone told us we’re crazy to get married, two survivors together, what’s the use of that, people asked us, but we did it anyways, she says proudly and passes pictures around of herself and her husband, he was the tallest and most handsome man on the volleyball team, she adds with a smile. They moved to Tokyo then, got themselves a store together and never mention a word about Hiroshima to anyone anymore. Only in the 1990s they would move back to Hiroshima, as the city gives survivors many benefits for living in the city after all. It’s here that I learned to speak about it again, she said. She worked as a calligrapher during the day before she retired, and at night she would speak endlessly of what had happened to them on that hot summer morning. “It was good that we came back to Hiroshima”, she says, folding her scarred hands in her lap, closing her story in this way.
“Four times at the museum in Hiroshima. I saw people walking around. People walk around, lost in thought, amongst the photographs. The photographs, the photographs, the reconstructions, for lack of anything else. The explanations, for lack of anything else. Four times at the museum in Hiroshima. (…) The illusion, quite simply, is so perfect that tourists weep. One can always scoff, but what else can a tourist do, but weep. I’ve always wept over Hiroshima’s fate. Always.”
(Hiroshima, Mon Amour)
“Let all the souls rest in peace, for we shall never repeat the mistake”, the inscription of the main shrine at the Peace Park says. A few steps away, the bodies of about 70,000 still unidentified corpses rest in a mass grave; the grave diggers were busy day and night back then, there was no time to waste on figuring out who it was they buried into the ground back then. Hamai Shinzo, the 1st elected mayor of Hiroshima was the one who then ordered the construction of the peace park only a few years after the bomb fell, on the very ground that used to be downtown Hiroshima. In 1947, the very first commemoration ceremony was held; only about a thousand citizens showed up. The U.S. military sent their official representatives to speak at the ceremony, and I imagine that the air must have been stiff with suppressed anger that morning, what kind of peace are these people talking about, many people wondered, with much of the city still in rubbles, with people jobless and starving, with those that pushed the button entirely in charge, but the commemoration ceremonies continued on, from year to year drawing an ever growing audience to shape the perception of the event; the peace park was established, the museum set in place, tourists poured into the city to treat on the ground that was charred by the very blast of the bomb, they fold paper cranes like us, look at the items on display, walk out from the museum a little numb, into the heat of a summer day, with the air filled with all the noise the crickets make, sitting in the trees of the peace park nearby.
The museum that I visited that day left me in sheer despair – half-way through it I realized that I could not look at a single item more, I hurried through the rest of the exhibition to find later that the only picture I had taken in the entire exhibition is that of a map I found hidden somewhere inside the many rooms – the Information and Intelligence Network of the U.S. military that is still stationed on Japanese soil up to this day – an elaborate graph showing a dense web of military alertness, a loud and bold “We are ready” screaming at those who look at that very graph. I think of Korea for a moment, of what peace means there, of what Cheong-hee had said to me a little while ago – how she already longs for Korea again, for the heavy debating and the daily contention that is Korea – every single person in this country, it sometimes seems, has a different idea of where to go with all the huge problems that the future will hold for the peninsula, you can’t think of peace without politics, she says, how would you wanna do that?

On the 6th of August we join the crowds at night – once the sun sets, thousands of lanterns with thousands of inscriptions of hope for peace are set into the river where thousands of corpses once swam. We are exhausted and cheerful, as we watch the lanterns drift past us, and right there, by the water – watching young children and grandparents, students and workers and teachers and tourists all alike as they gaze at the nightly river and the A-bomb dome that stands brightly alit this night – I have a single moment when I feel like I can touch what Hiroshima is about. Mariko, a peace activist born and raised in Hiroshima that I talked to earlier that day, had said that after all these years she is still frustrated and at the same time obsessed with that one thought: that we shall never truly be able to understand what happened that day to those in the center of Hiroshima. Hiroshima, perhaps, is all about making the futile attempt at trying nevertheless. Perhaps, if thousands of lanterns drift down a river that was once filled red with blood, perhaps if tens of thousands of people stand silently in awe, perhaps somehow, somewhere, a little bit of the horror in fact can be alleviated. It’s the only hope we truly have.
24 hours after we left Hiroshima, we hear the news of Georgia, and I sit in my room in Seoul in silence, and now I finally weep.